My Favorite Christmas Reads
Through The Decades
I've blogged sporadically over the years about my favorite books - in 2025 I hope to better organize those posts, and clean up some of the older ones. This is my attempt to "consolidate" my Christmas Reads posts. As with everything, it's a work in progress!
My reading taste leans towards mostly mysteries, police procedurals, some thrillers. Character development is more important to me than I would have realized on my own - but my daughter was an English major, and she points these things out. :-) I also love to learn - so historical fiction, non fiction and memoirs often fill my to read piles. Romance is probably my least favorite genre. At Christmas time I am more likely to pick up "fluff" - usually in the form of cozy mysteries.
===================
MY ALL TIME FAVORITES
The ones I recommend to everyone
(On down below I have more lists, by themes)
Mr. Dickens & His Carol By Silva. Historical Fiction "that reimagines the story behind Charles Dickens' Christmas classic" | Midwinter Murder A collection of short stories by Agatha Christie
|
Donna Andrews - all of the Christmas versions. Light, and fun, borderline ridiculous, always a favorite for me. |
Christmas Bells by Chiaverini is well done historical fiction about the history behind Longfellow's Poem of the same name.
|  The Most Wonderful Crime Of The year by Ally Carter. A Romcom mystery that I enjoyed so much more than I would have expected, in 2024 |  These are short reads. SMART cozies, not silly, but oh so humorous. The perfect audio books for our short Christmas road trips - my husband and I loved these. |

The New Hercule Poirot Series By Sophie Hannah Silent Night |  Benjamin Stevenson has become of of my new favorite "light" mystery authors. I've thoroughly enjoyed every book in this series - including the Christmas read.
| The Ghost Of Christmas Past by Rhys Bowen is a Historical Fiction Cozy Mystery. We listened to this one as an audiobook on a family road trip one Christmas - we all enjoyed it |
Swamp Santa Book 16 in the Miss Fortune Series. Laugh out loud, ridiculous but in a super fun way. I read every book in this series as fast as I can get my hands on them.
| | |
========================
Series Christmas
Many of these are books that I first read at Christmas time, then found I liked enough to want to read the rest of the series. Cozy Mysteries, for the most part.
|
These are short reads. SMART cozies, not silly, but oh so humorous. The perfect audio books for our short Christmas road trips - my husband and I loved these.
|
My daughter and I both love the Donna Andrews series. We spot the anomalies, the errors, the ridiculousness of some of the stories.. and we keep reading because we love the characters and they are fun.
|
Benjamin Stevenson has become of of my new favorite "light" mystery authors. I've thoroughly enjoyed every book in this series - including the Christmas read.
|
|
Christmas On Ladybug Farm Light & Sweet - not a mystery I loved this entire series
|
When Christmas Comes by Andrew Klavan
|
41.5 in the Spencer series. The only one I have ever read, but I REALLY liked it, and should add the series to my to read list...
|

The New Hercule Poirot Series By Sophie Hannah
| Rest You Merry Charlotte MacLeod I can't say I remember reading this, but apparently I gave it 5 stars on goodreads at the time... I did not yet read the rest of the series. |
 Rhys Bowen Royal Spyness & Molly Murphy Sereis both have Christmas books - I enjoy both series. Light mysteries. |
Swamp Santa Book 16 in the Miss Fortune Series. Laugh out loud, ridiculous but in a super fun way. I read every book in this series as fast as I can get my hands on them. | | |
On My To Read List
Lord Edgington Investigates Series by Benedict Brown
Mordecai Tremaine series by Francis Duncan
Bibliophile Mysteries by Kate Carlisle
The Christmas Boutique by Jennifer Chiaverini
Not For Me:
The Camile Devine Series by Andrea Hicks has a lot of Christmas themed books in it. I read the first one, it wasn't terrible, but I don't feel the need to try the others.
===================
Christmas Classics
|
 Letters From Father Christmas by J.R.R. Tolkien |

|
Jacob T. Marley by Bennet is probably not truly a classic - but it expands on a classic... so well so that it almost fees like historical fiction.
|
|
|
|
|
On My To Read List:
Marley by Jon Clinch
Old Christmas by Washington Irving
Charles Dickens - A Christmas Tree; What Christmas is as we Grow Older; The Poor Relation's Story; The Child's Story; The Schoolboy's Story; Nobody's Story.
========================
Christmas Historical Fiction That I Enjoyed
|
Mr. Dickens & His Carol By Silva. Historical Fiction "that reimagines the story behind Charles Dickens' Christmas classic"
|
|
Christmas Bells by Chiaverini is well done historical fiction about the history behind Longfellow's Poem of the same name.
|
|
|
|
|
Note - Fannie Flagg's Redbird Christmas comes up as the most recommended Christmas read in almost all of my book circles. I think I tried it one year and just couldn't get into it - but so much of my reading is dependent on my mood - I may try it again.

m
Here's a List Of 20 Christmas Reads
Suggested by Historical Fiction Readers
On My To Read List
Christmas With The Queen by Hazel Gaynor
Small Things Like These by Claire Keegan (typically if a book has an Oprah's bookclub sticker on it, I will not touch it - Oprah and I have extremely divergent taste in books. However, this one was also recommended by someone whom usually recommends good books...)
========================
Christmas Crime - Light Mysteries
(Fun, but not too over the top ridiculous)
Cozy Christmas/Funny Romcom. My favorite Christmas read of 2024. | Murder After Christmas By Rupert Latimer Classic Mystery | |
| | |
On My To Read List:
Murder On A Winter Afternoon by Betty Rowlands
==========================
Christmas Crime - Dark Christmas
Stories that were not exactly holly & jolly, but that I still enjoyed
|
|
|
This is an entire series - all winter/snow... I read the first one and it was good. Not great, but good.
|
|
|
|
|
On my to read list:
Her Last Christmas by Claire McGowan
=======================
Christmas Crime
Cozies bordering on Ridiculous
I suppose these are my guilty pleasures. :-)
Christmas Tree Farm Series By Jacqueline Frost Never going to make my favorites list, but good enough that I keep reading the series | Murder In The Manger by Debbie Young Book 3 in the Sophie Sayers series - the only book I've read in this series.
| |
| | |
On My To Read List
A Year Round Christmas Mystery Series by Vicki Delaney
==========================
Christmas Spirit -
Light and Sweet (could possibly inspire a Hallmark Movie)
|
The Christmas Train by David Baldacci
|
The Christmas Pig by J.K. Rowling
|
|
|
|
|
|
Haven't Yet Read, But Looked Interesting:
Jennie Colgan has at least a couple of book themed cozy (no mystery) Christmas Reads
The Journey of Joseph Winter: A Christmas Fairy Tale by John Anthony
The Other Wise Man by Henry Van Dyke
===================
Factual Christmas
Non Fiction & Memoirs
The Man Who Invented Christmas by Standiford I read this a LONG time ago - and mostly I remember that it was short, and not as good as Dickens & His Carol by Silva. But I'm pretty sure I still enjoyed this..
| Bill Bryson's Secret History Of Christmas - I listened to this one, and I remember it being light, fun, and interesting.
| |
| | |
On my to read list:
The True Story of The Christmas Truth by Anthony Richards
Village Christmas by Laurie Lee
The True Saint Nichlas by William Bennet
=========================================================
NOT FOR ME
================
Read for a book club - the twelve dates of Christmas
Not horrible, just not for me. :-) Typical Christmas Romance
Murder On The Christmas Express by Alexandra Benedict
Twelve Drummers Drumming - Father Christmas #1
by C.C. Bennison. My entire goodreads review, from 2011, is "Long. Tedious."
===============
From 2017 - My Favorite Christmas Reads
==================
I keep a list of books of Christmas themed books that I want to read, and as with my full to read list, it grows faster than I can possibly read. (Often my Christmas reading list introduces me to new series, which extends my general to read list... ) Looking back over my goodreads list, I have definitely made a dent over the years, these were some of my favorites:
Christmas Classics:
"A young boy and his mother spend Christmas 1943 with relatives in northern Minnesota while his father is fighting in the war in Europe. They take a long journey by train to a snowy land of vast frozen lakes, deep and sparkling cold, and the most magical Christmas tree the boy has ever seen. He knows this will be the last Christmas he will spend with his cousin, who is dying. The boy's uncle overhears the two cousins say there is no Santa Claus, and in a grand gesture that is nothing short of a Christmas miracle, he restores the children's faith in the spirit of the season." - Goodreads
Cozy Christmas
(Light reads, but not mysteries)
The Christmas Wedding by James Patterson
Another Patterson that I liked a lot - this one is not a mystery.
Comfort & Joy by Kristin Hannah
Kristin Hannah is another of my favorite authors, and while this is far from my favorite book by her, it's a good read. Like many others, it's a typical Hallmark Christmas Movie plot. Divorced woman, goes on a trip to avoid the holidays, makes a detour, crosses path with a child who has recently lost his mother. " When the little boy meets Joy, these two unlikely souls form a deep and powerful bond. In helping Bobby and Daniel heal, Joy finds herself again. But not everything is as it seems in quiet Rain Valley, and in an instant, Joy’s world is ripped apart, and her heart is broken. On a magical Christmas Eve, a night of impossible dreams and unexpected chances, Joy must find the courage to believe in a love—and a family—that can’t possibly exist, and go in search of what she wants . . . and the new life only she can find."
Lost December by Richard Paul Evans
A retelling of the story of the Prodigal son
The Christmas Box Trilogy by Richard Paul Evans
Looking for short, sweet, and sappy? This will be a great choice.
The Mistletoe Series by Richard Paul Evans
Three Christmas romances - each one is the plot of a Hallmark Christmas movie. Quick reads.
The Noel Series by Richard Paul Evans
Labeled "The King Of Christmas Fiction" on Amazon, this series by Evans is one I have not yet read. The first is about a son, returning to his family home after his mothers death.
"Jacob’s mother had become a hoarder and he must excavate through two decades worth of clutter. As Jacob digs through the detritus, like an archaeologist, he uncovers many puzzling items including a diary left by someone named Noel, a young woman he has no recollection of, who stayed with Jacob’s family during her pregnancy. That’s not the only echo from the past. Jacob has an unexpected visitor, Rachel, a woman looking for the mother who put her up for adoption thirty years before. United by their quest to make sense of the past and rewrite their futures, Jacob and Rachel begin a search for Noel. Along the way they find more than they possibly imagined, including grace, forgiveness and a chance at love."
Cozy Christmas Mysteries
Another one of my favorite (mystery) series, Her Royal Spyness. This is book 6 in the series, it's stand alone, you don't need to read the first 5 to love this book. Although once you read it, you might want to read the whole series....
Georgie is 35th in line to the throne, expected to live as royalty, but with no income to do so. As she moves from home to home, and visits with the queen, she stumbles into all sorts of mysteries, and of course, solves them.
Duck The Halls by Donna Andrews
A Meg Lanslow mystery - book #6. If you are looking for a silly mystery, with lots of laughs, try this one.
The Holiday Grind by Cleo Coyle
There are two Christmas books in this series.. this one I liked a lot, the other was just ok. This is another series I would love to read more of.. mysteries set in a coffee house!
A Christmas To Die For by Marta Perry
I read this and loved it even before I learned that this is a local author, who I eventually met at our local library! An Amish mystery.
More about Marta Perry
A Highland Christmas by M.C. Beaton
Another charming (but not TOO sweet) Cozy Mystery. This was my first introduction to Hamish Macbeth. I keep meaning to read the rest of this series, but I have not yet gotten back to it...
Rest Ye Merry - a Peter Shandy Mystery by Charlotte McLeod
An extremely light, traditional, Christmas mystery
A Christmas scrooge discovers a murdered librarian in this holiday novel from an Edgar Award finalist known for her “witty, literate, and charming” mysteries (Publishers Weekly).
Christmas Detective Stories

Hercule Poirot's Christmas by Agatha Christie
The Hercule Poirot series is one of my favorites!
There's also The Adventure Of the Christmas Pudding
The Christmas Mystery by James Patterson
This is a bookshot - less than 100 pages I think... it's a Detective Luc Moncrief mystery. (There are a lot of Patterson's books that I do NOT like, this is one series I like a lot.)
Silent Night by Robert Parker
A Spenser Novel - this book was unfinished when Parker died, it was finished by his agent.
My Christmas Reads, 2024
Did not enjoy: Mistletoe Mystery [I do not like this series - why do I keep reading them??], The Christmas Appeal [Loved the story and the characters, did not enjoy the format - story is told through whatsapp chats and emails] The Christmas Party [Audible audio - overly predictable and done too many times "thriller"]
I didn't dislike, but got a bit bored with:
Murder Most Festive & Sherlock Holmes and the Christmas Demon. I would be willing to give both authors another chance, I really WANTED to love James Lovegrove's Sherlock, but this book was not spectacular.
Enjoyed: I have really been enjoying the "Everyone" series by Benjamin Stevenson this year, this Christmas read was no exception. Also, I've been devouring the Donna Andrews books, in order this year, and they are one of my favorite series. We listened to Let It Crow on audio on family Christmas light viewing trips. Same with the Andy Carpenter series - they are my go to audiobooks for road trips with my husband. We listened to The More The Terrier, and it did not disappoint.
The Standouts : Ok, I have read Peter Swanson. I should have known what I was in for. But... this caught me off guard. It is certainly not the best thing I read this season, but it was so different, and memorable, that it is a "stand out" for me.
The Most Wonderful Crime Of The Year was a delightful surprise - Agatha Christie style locked room in a traditional English Christmas Setting, and also a Romcom. This is the book I recommended to everyone this Christmas season - it was fun, and well written.
Andrew Keavan and Denzil Meyrick were both new authors for me this year - and both were added to "read more" list. Murder at Holly House, by Meyrick, is book one, and there is a second Christmas book that will be at the top of my Christmas to read list in 2025. When Christmas Comes by Andrew Klavan is book one in a 4 book series. [Book 4 was released October 2024]. I look forward to reading more of the series, and I recommended it to my husband and stepfather, I think both of them will enjoy it too.
=================
READ MORE
=================
===================